Progressives in Congressional elections: Missouri
Post columnist David Von Drehle has a piece, "What Lacy Clay’s primary loss reminds us about generational house-cleanings," commenting on the defeat of "moderate" William Lacy Clay in a St. Louis-focused Congressional district primary by Justice Democrats-endorsed Cori Bush.
He argues that Clay took the position for granted--between he and his father, a Clay held the office for more than 50 years--but that there is something to be said for moderation.
That's true, but I think there is a difference between moderation and not doing very much at all.
What happened in Ferguson, Missouri, not just the death of Michael Brown, but the spawning of the Black Lives Matter movement and the months-long demonstrations in St. Louis County as a result, ought to have been a wake up call to William Lacy Clay. If not Ferguson, definitely the success of Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez in 2018, especially after he faced similar opposition in the 2018 primary, also by Cori Bush.
Just off hand, from what I know about St. Louis City and County and/or subsequent press coverage (e.g., "Policing for Profit in St. Louis County," New York Times), I'd say there should be a very clear agenda, including:
- a city-county merger to better balance tax revenues and services across the county ("5 Takeaways From A City-County Merger Plan That Never Got To Voters," St. Louis Public Radio)
- using court fines as a municipal funding stream
- consolidation of some of the dinky towns that use court fines as a funding stream
- addressing the economic decline of St. Louis
- addressing the discriminatory structure of policing in St. Louis county
- creating a county policing authority to dissolve as many of the dinky, discriminatory police departments as possible, along the Camden model ("Camden police reboot is being misused in the debate over police reform," Washington Post)
- etc.
While I don't agree with his politics, The Next American City: The Big Promise of Our Midsize Metros by Mick Cornett, the former Mayor of Oklahoma City, outlines a great approach to rejuvenating a city.
The OKC program is called "Metropolitan Area Projects" and is a great example of what I call Transformational Projects Action Planning.
Each round--there have been four--focus on significant capital projects that have transformed the city's downtown, the Bricktown canal district, center city schools and neighborhoods, and the Oklahoma River waterfront, among others. Another example, building an arena, but without a tenant enabled the city to land an NBA team.
One of the most recent capital projects that has been delivered is a downtown streetcar. They are already working on expansion.
Similarly, Hennepin County Minnesota created a program called Hennepin Community Works to reinvest in Minneapolis to staunch population loss and disinvestment.
Yes there is generational change. But Nancy Pelosi is 78 years old, and she's kicking butt.
Still, I am super impressed that Justice Democrats figured out that they could win in heavily Democratic seats, and from those positions, could shift the national agenda in a progressive agenda.
Although they haven't figured out that those kinds of seats are a relatively small set of the total number. That it's not likely they'll win in seats that aren't so overwhelmingly Democratic.
Still, a number of JD-endorsed candidates have won primaries in this cycle so that the number of hard core progressives is likely to at least double. Rashida Tlaib easily held off her primary challenger, currently the chair of the Detroit City Council. Although we won't know til next week if Ilhan Omar will hold her seat in Minneapolis. I'm thinking no, but we'll see ("Rep. Omar faces well-funded, moderate challengers in heated District 5 Democratic primary," Duluth News-Tribune), although with four challengers she may well squeak by.
5 Comments:
https://www.mercatus.org/bridge/commentary/looking-glass-politics
Look, Merctaus is a paid subsidiary of Koch Inc, but I've quoted the author before -- he wrote "Revolt of the public" which is a good outline of the populist revolt going on now.
Basically -- all social media.
I very much agree with your list of "needs" for something like St Louis -- although there is always room for local knowledge -- and you'll notice that none of them are in the list of demands.
Somewhat remisinct of the HK protests but they had "5 demands and not one more" -- which was concrete but never going to happen.
MORE TO READ.
Social media has some good elements. It enables organizing, allows for creating practice networks that normally would be severely bounded, etc.
But there is so much f*ed up about social media. I barely participate (and therefore my blog is lapped, at the least I should twitter out each new entry and I don't even do that).
I think there are some great things about the various applications like Instagram, Pinterest, Twitter. But a lot terrible. And I am unfamiliar with the video based applications.
And frankly I just don't have enough time to wade through it all.
Cancel culture is pretty f*ed. I prefer discourse.
BUT... the Klinenberg book does discuss social media, mostly weighing in negatively. He discusses Lawrence Haidt and others.
It happens that I had just read a couple columns about Lawrence Haidt by Paul Kelly in the Australian.
Kelly is pretty amazing and the Australian has a strict paywall. Either you access through a library database or a paywall bypasser (I use the latter but the former in a pince; https://github.com/iamadamdev/bypass-paywalls-chrome).
Haidt is at NYU, writes books, etc. I need to look more at his work.
2020, on "the West"
https://www.theaustralian.com.au/inquirer/the-uncivil-war-killing-liberalism-in-the-west/news-story/2a4d7fb78ce58ea6752a491bc4113487
2019, about the US
https://www.theaustralian.com.au/nation/politics/very-good-chance-democracy-is-doomed-in-america-says-haidt/news-story/0106ec1c458a0b5e3844545514a55b5a
https://www.theaustralian.com.au/inquirer/americas-uncivil-war-on-democracy/news-story/45a86ac9b438b85dce0bbbd289e1604e
charlie offers this resource:
http://papers.nber.org/tmp/59388-w27651.pdf
wrt demands, I just don't remember if I was like that back in the day on campus, etc. I always did have a pragmatic side, joking that Nestle was the only bad multinational vis a vis the infant formula boycott.
Yes, I am normative focused ("we should") and not always practical.
In terms of demands it's like the old discussions about the difference between goals and objectives. Goals are visionary, aspirational "we should" while objectives are specific and actionable.
Goal
Defund Police
????? which plays badly among people concerned about crime and chaos
Objective
1. Redesign 911/311 to deliver calls to differentiated array of services.
2. DEFINITELY train the call center operators WAY BETTER so that they fully convey necessary information.
3. Create and fund mental health assistance teams that don't rely on guns for compliance.
4. Create and fund "neighborhood warden" systems to deal with persistent nuisance problems (I am gonna write about this wrt the chaos and nuisances that collect in the neighborhoods around homeless shelters, using some SLC matters as an example).
5. Better hiring for police. Psychological assessments etc. like in the UK.
6. Way more training of police, like other countries.
7. Super duper training and assessment for authorization to carry guns, etc.
=============
I am still easing into Utah, but I am pretty impressed with the woman, Lex Scott, who created Black Lives Utah. I don't agree with her on everything, but she is focused, and focused on structural change.
https://www.deseret.com/opinion/2020/6/29/21307639/black-lives-matter-utah-founder-racism-police-brutality-protests-lex-scott-civil-rights
https://www.sltrib.com/news/2020/08/02/doors-slammed-her-face/
From the "Justice Democrats" perspective, I hope we can get her to run in 2022 for Congress against that !@#$%^&*()_ Chris Stewart in D2. (I live about 1-2 miles from the border of the Congressional District represented by Ben McAdams.
Again, wrt "demands" as you know, living in crime ridden cities really really sucks.
I have no sympathy for people who commit crimes for the most part, especially crimes of violence.
The people who argue defund police seem to be completely disconnected from the reality of what it was like to be in center cities in the 1980s and 1990s when things were really really bad.
I can't count the number of times my bike or parts were stolen. Petty thefts from my yard. Burglaries. Stolen (rental) car. At least three muggings (I managed to get away every time) plus avoiding others.
Multiple burglaries plus the rape of my then wife. A freak assault of me by a wack job when I was locking my bike. (I followed him for miles across the city til I could get him arrested. At the trial, I realized he clearly was mentally ill.)
Etc.
Who wants a return to that time of terror?
Post a Comment
<< Home