Rebuilding Place in the Urban Space

"A community’s physical form, rather than its land uses, is its most intrinsic and enduring characteristic." [Katz, EPA] This blog focuses on place and placemaking and all that makes it work--historic preservation, urban design, transportation, asset-based community development, arts & cultural development, commercial district revitalization, tourism & destination development, and quality of life advocacy--along with doses of civic engagement and good governance watchdogging.

Wednesday, July 23, 2025

New interpretation of courtyard housing in Chicago says F.U. to the street

Courtyard housing is a home-y type where instead of houses on either side of a block facing the street, there is sidewalk and somewhat communal public space, open to the neighborhood in which it's embedded.  Apartments use the type too, organized as a horseshoe around communal space.  

Ross Chapin's Pocket Neighborhoods is about the type, and it's beautifully written.

It would be considered "missing middle housing," but I think that's somewhat of a mis-classification.  Or at least, I think the communal/non-street elements are more important to focus on.

It's more of group oriented housing development rather than a focus on single occupant dwellings as 

Design-wise, except for it being apartments and a locked entry way, the set up of the apartment building on the tv show Melrose Place is similar, except the pool functions the common space.  This building reintroduced us to courtyard housing.


Pre-war apartment buildings often used this physical design without a focus on developing communal elements of the space.

Salt Lake has a bunch of good SFH examples, including Boulevard Gardens.  I just saw "a new to me" one on 800 East.


Crain's Chicago Business has a story,"Architects' redesign of a Chicago classic becoming reality in the West Side," about how two architectural firms have created a modern version.  The exterior, butt ugly, has no charm, and it's perpendicular to the street so that the courtyard is disconnected and focused only on the residents within.  There isn't much charm.  I can't imagine there's much communal activity in the space.  They miss the point on what community and connectedness mean.




Labels: , , ,

2 Comments:

At 7:40 PM, Blogger Richard Layman said...

Financial Times, https://archive.ph/UB2UH
7/25/25

Inside Welborne, the new town making its own rules
The architect-led ‘garden village’ is hoping to demonstrate how high-volume housing delivery can pair with high design

“It is not necessary to put up with the very dull and not necessarily very good product that comes from most of the national housebuilders, that has no community and nothing invested up front,” he says. He is striving to achieve “much better quality . . . Most choose not to, for both time and money reasons.”

While volume housebuilders are tools for councils to deliver on mandatory housing targets — the current Labour government has committed to delivering 1.5mn homes by 2029 — they have also come under scrutiny for underdelivering on design quality.

In its recent report, Design for Neighbourhoods, the Design Council — the UK’s national strategic adviser for design — argued that “too many recent homes fail to meet acceptable standards, with 74 per cent rated as mediocre or poor”, drawing on 2021 data from the Place Alliance, a research and advocacy organisation based at University College London. The report recommends that housebuilding is paired with investment in infrastructure, public space, “placemaking” and long-term management and maintenance.

Thistlethwayte’s vision of “much better quality” at Welborne includes the adoption of traditional architectural styles that “pass the test of time” and reflect local vernacular, alongside an abundance of carefully maintained green space. The development has been designed by architect Ben Pentreath, and the landscape vision drawn up by architect Kim Wilkie. The early integration of community facilities such as a primary school, GP practice, shops, pub and village hall — all of which will be delivered in the first phase — is a key part of what Thistlethwayte sees as placemaking.

... Committed to ensuring that the designs are followed through, Thistlethwayte brought on board regional small and medium-scale housebuilders — including CG Fry & Son, Thakeham and Pye Homes — to deliver the vision for Welborne. Pentreath describes a “collaborative approach” with the housebuilders, but also a “very tight net of quality control”.

 
At 8:18 PM, Blogger Richard Layman said...

In its recent report, Design for Neighbourhoods, the Design Council — the UK’s national strategic adviser for design — argued that “too many recent homes fail to meet acceptable standards, with 74 per cent rated as mediocre or poor”, drawing on 2021 data from the Place Alliance, a research and advocacy organisation based at University College London. The report recommends that housebuilding is paired with investment in infrastructure, public space, “placemaking” and long-term management and maintenance.

https://issuu.com/designcouncil/docs/design_for_neighbourhoods

Design for Neighbourhoods: A design agenda for the new government

 

Post a Comment

<< Home