Rebuilding Place in the Urban Space

"A community’s physical form, rather than its land uses, is its most intrinsic and enduring characteristic." [Katz, EPA] This blog focuses on place and placemaking and all that makes it work--historic preservation, urban design, transportation, asset-based community development, arts & cultural development, commercial district revitalization, tourism & destination development, and quality of life advocacy--along with doses of civic engagement and good governance watchdogging.

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Non-evidence based policymaking: Speed cameras

Research shows that speed camera ticketing systems reduces driver speeding ("Evaluating the Effectiveness of Urban Speed Cameras on Traffic Safety in a Period of Dramatic Change," National University Center for Promoting Safety).

Pro-car forces, "muh freedom (to break the law)," fight them vociferously.  Especially conservatives.  For example, the Utah State Legislature has preempted local governments from having such systems.

Doug Ford the Prime Minister of Ontario is supra big on local preemption, especially on what he sees is fighting the "war on cars" ("Doug Ford rails against the three-pronged war on the car," National Post)  So he forced Toronto to decommission speed cameras.  Same with bike lanes ("Toronto cyclists ask Canada's top court to weigh in on Ford's bike lane removal plan," CBC News, "Bikes v cars: backlash after Ontario premier threatens to tear up cycling lanes in Toronto," Guardian).

“It’s a clear war on the cars. They’re going to St. Clair-ize the whole city and turn it into a St. Clair disaster, number one. The other war on cars is they want to toll the cars… the other war on cars is the medical officer of health commenting to reduce the speed. Maybe the Medical Officer of Health should stick with the medical profession and not the transportation profession. So, we have three attacks on the cars and the taxpayers of the city.”

Now, drivers on those roads are speeding much more, according to the Toronto Star, "Doug Ford banned speed cameras a year ago. On Toronto roads where they stood, speeding has tripled, Star analysis reveals."

I make the point that social justice types decriminalizing certain types of crimes because the penalties were unfair ended up increasing crime, because law breakers didn't take this as forgiveness and recognition of dire circumstances--they saw it as a cue to commit more crime.

It's impossible to have enough traffic enforcement officers to enforce traffic laws, so automated systems--speed cameras and traffic light cameras especially, systems on buses to capture violators driving in bus lanes, toll evaders, etc.--are necessary to reduce bad behavior.

Interestingly, a poll by CityNews television station finds that 70% of Toronto residents support speed cameras (video below).

Labels: , ,

(Revisiting) Parking, parking, parking

Flickr photo by Robby Virus.

Say that in the tone of Jan Brady complaining about Marcia getting all the attention on the Brady Bunch.

The joke is that parking is the third rail of local politics, reflecting the pro car agenda of most residents, residents who are imprinted with a car first urban planning paradigm, even if they don't recognize it.  

Parking in front of your house.  According to the San Francisco Chronicle ("East Bay CEO steps down after threatening Spanish speakers over parking space"), that sense of entitlement ended up costing Oakland resident Dr. Lesleigh Franklin her job. From the article:

An Oakland psychologist stepped down from her role as chief executive officer of an East Bay mental health clinic after she was captured on video Aug. 4 claiming to be an immigration attorney and demanding that a group of people speaking Spanish and English move their parked vehicle from the curb in front of her home.

Same old, same old.  One of the reasons I don't write so much is I believe I've said so many of these things already, as the Talking Heads sang in "Psychokiller," "Say something once, why say it again?"

-- "City Parking" 2015
-- "Testimony on parking policy in DC," 2012

Good sum up of the opportunity costs imposed by mandatory parking requirements.  But a piece in the Boston Globe, "Should Boston prioritize new housing over parking?," sums up the issue pretty well in terms of how requiring parking, and certainly requiring more parking than there is demand for it, drives up the cost of housing, both for owner occupied and rental.  From the article:

We’re going to find out on Wednesday how serious the Boston City Council is about solving the housing crisis.

Councilors are expected to take a crucial vote on whether to eliminate a citywide requirement for off-street parking with most new housing development. Study after study has shown that this one simple change to the zoning code can have an outsized impact on lowering the cost of construction and spurring new housing.

... The city of Boston has been relaxing parking requirements for large housing proposals that go through the city’s development review process, as well as for certain affordable housing projects. This proposed amendment aims to help everyone else – from homeowners adding an accessory dwelling unit (where parking is now required) to developers of six-unit buildings, who need to figure out where to put 12 parking spaces. It would not ban parking; rather it allows developers to decide how many spaces are needed.

It includes data on the cost of parking underground and on the surface.  And, like some one off studies I've seen in DC about apartment buildings near Metrorail stops, the article references a Boston area study that found 33% of parking provided in multiunit buildings went unused.

Downtown Park and Shop ad, Washington Star, 4/10/1968.

Donald Shoup, the professor most focused on the issue ("He puts parking in its place," Los Angeles Times, "Donald Shoup, professor famed for his innovations in parking policy, dies").  

A big point made by Professor Donald Shoup about parking was the high amount of public space--curb space--provided for parking, 15% or more of a city's public space, and that it could be used for other purposes having more value.

Subsidizing car owners for street parking.  In DC, I complain about how car owners pay far less to use public space than residents using car sharing services, as a way to not own a car--and as a form of transportation demand management.  High charges to the services, plus trip charges to the user are many times that of a resident parking permit.  It's probably a factor, albeit small, in the failure of Car2Go and Free2Move in DC.

-- "DC proposes ride hailing tax of 6%: It's not enough--car share users pay 10%," 2018

Shared parking, planning at the district scale.  This doesn't happen much, but I wrote about it.

-- "Parking districts vs. transportation/urban management districts: Part one, Bethesda," 2015
-- "Parking districts vs. transportation/urban management districts: Part two, Takoma DC/Takoma Park Maryland," 2015
-- "Parking districts vs. transportation/urban management districts: Part three, jitneys/shuttles/delivery and the tertiary transit network," 2015

Henry Grabar's book on parking.  I never read it because I figured Shoup covered it all, but it does put the issue in a much more readable way.

-- Review, New York Times
-- "'Paved Paradise' examines how parking has changed the American landscape," NPR
-- "This book about parking will change how you see the world," Los Angeles Times

Judging based on the articles, I should read it.

Labels: , , , ,

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Los Angeles Mayor Elect Nithya Raman is a community planner

The mayor-elect of Los Angeles, Nithya Raman, during her election night watch party in November. Photo: Philip Cheung for The New York Times

I mentioned that Congressman Elect Brad Lander is a community planner ("Congressman Elect Brad Lander of New York (City)").  So is the incoming Mayor of Los Angeles, Nithya Raman ("What Nithya Raman Plans to Do First as L.A. Mayor," New York Times).  From the article:

Ms. Raman, a 45-year-old member of the Los Angeles City Council with a master’s degree in urban planning, didn’t talk about defunding police, removing the private sector from housing construction or other items from a D.S.A. wish list. Rather, she outlined a near future of mapping out trouble spots and restructuring org charts. She would launch dashboards and audits, she said, and base performance evaluations on results and metrics. In her pursuit of a more livable city, she would drill down to a “nitty-gritty” so granular that it would “make your eyes glaze over.”

“In just one century, Los Angeles built itself into a global metropolis, the gateway to the Pacific, a center of ingenuity and invention, and the cultural capital of the entire planet,” Ms. Raman exhorted. “Don’t tell me the city of Los Angeles can’t fix a streetlight!”

When I was thinking about running for City Council in DC, I wrote out a suggested platform and agenda for a Councilmember, and it included the use of data collection and dashboards for monitoring, identifying, and responding to issues in the Ward.

-- "Outline for a proposed Ward-focused (DC) Councilmember campaign platform and agenda," 2015 

An "ad" in the Instagram feed of the Nithya Raman mayoral campaign.

Christopher Hawthorne, ex-architecture critic for the Los Angeles Times and then Chief Design Officer for Mayor Garcetti, wrote about her in the e-letter Punch List, "What to know about Nithya Raman."  From the article:

“I'm a planner first and foremost, and a politician as a means to an end,” she said in a 2022 interview. Her professional experience is varied. She spent two stints in her native India working to improve sanitation in poor neighborhoods, in Delhi and then Chennai. Before winning a council seat in 2020, she held a job with L.A.’s city administrative officer, or CAO, founded a nonprofit working to curb homelessness, and served as executive director of the Hollywood branch of Time’s Up.

Labels: , , , , ,

This doesn't make people feel better, but ...

-- "Schools Are Closing Nationwide as Enrollment Drops. Parents Are Livid," New York Times 

People focus on their own community, not acknowledging the demographic issues are the same in most cities that are already built up.

I was looking at Oakland County, Michigan where I went to high school and I presumed school closings, for example Royal Oak once had two high schools each with more than 2,000 students, and now they only have one, were due to population losses.  Yes, but no.  Oakland County's population went up, but the percentage of school aged children dropped.

WRT public schooling, vouchers and charter schools make the problem even worse.  I don't criticize parents for choosing charter schools, because they are aiming for the best for their child(ren).  But it does diminish the public school in many ways:

  • enrollments
  • community involvement
  • community connection.
I've written that the basic building block for healthy neighborhoods is good elementary school.  Charters and vouchers disconnect school enrollment from neighborhoods.

You see it in my greater neighborhood.  The east side of Salt Lake City is still fecund.  There are three elementary schools and two junior highs.  All have high walk to school rates.  But that's atypical for the region.  Most school districts with schools on the east side facing the Wasatch Front are closing schools.  Salt Lake is too, but in the central and west sides.

A new way to build school enrollments: a school open late every day, to accommodate working parents
("The 7-Days-a-Week, 12-Months-a-Year School," New York Magazine). From the article:
The school, called Strive Charter School, opened in August. It was founded not with a lofty pedagogical mandate or unique classroom-behavior strategy but with the goal of making life significantly easier for working parents. The founder, Eric Grannis, takes pride in Strive’s academic offerings but knows that the school’s main selling point is its hours of operation. Horacio learned about Strive over the summer, when he was handed a pamphlet at the entrance to a subway station. “Open from 7am to 7pm,” the paper read. “7 days a week, 12 months a year.”

During the regular school year — from September to late June — class is in session five days a week, from 9 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. The extended part of the schedule (early mornings, evenings, weekends, and July and August) is optional and free of charge. Those hours will be filled with a variety of programming: tutoring, sports, art, music, viewings in a planetarium, and free play. In the summer, the full week will run like a classic day camp with some additional academic components, including required reading periods, tutoring, and enrichment. Dropping off and picking up a child outside of regular school hours, according to Grannis, should be as simple as stopping by Starbucks for a preordered cup of coffee.

In Strive, Grannis has embraced a dual role for schools as both centers of education and an integral form of child care that many teachers and administrators have long resisted. But the vast majority of working parents in America depend on schools to do their jobs, and Grannis believes educational institutions can and should do even more to help parents stay employed.
Past writings on school issues:


Labels: , , , , , ,

Wednesday, November 11, 2026

Congressman Elect Brad Lander of New York (City)

Got his start as a community revitalization advocate, leading an organization in Brooklyn called the Fifth Avenue Committee.  I referenced it a few times early on in the blog.  From there he went on to run the Pratt Institute's Center for Community Development. 

-- Pratt Center for Community Development

Then he became a City Council member, then the City's Comptroller.  As Comptroller he provided oversight, analysis, and reports on the operations of various government agencies and issues before the government.

Zohran Mamdani and Brad Lander campaigning together in Brooklyn in June, just before the Democratic primary for mayor.  Photo: Hiroko Masuike/The New York Times.

He then ran for mayor in the same election as Zohran Mamdani.  During the campaign, Mamdani and Lander joined forces of a sort, saying that voting for either of them promoted a progressive agenda. After the Mayoral election, rather than take a Deputy Mayor position, he decided to run for Congress ("The Strategic Uncoupling of Zohran Mamdani and Brad Lander," New York Times).

Congress doesn't get into the nitty gritty of issues like it did in the past--e.g. amazing hearings on various urban issues, transportation, poverty, etc.

But it's nice to have in Congress someone committed deeply to a pro-city agenda.

====

About 20 years ago, I heard Congressman Mike Taylor of Ohio, former Republican Mayor of Dayton ("For Mike Turner, a shocking defeat echoes a shocking beginning," Dayton Daily News), speak at a small conference and I was impressed by his focus on urban issues.  At the time.  Before Mayor, he was chair of the city's Board of Zoning Appeals.  That's nitty gritty local government.

He regressed more into a typical Republican toadie over time, although he did do a lot of bipartisan things, and ended up as chair of the House Intelligence Committee.  This year, he lost his bid for reelection (" ‘A major shakeup’: Knickerbocker unseats Turner in Congress," DDN).  Although he has filed papers to be able to run again ("Turner opens door for run to retake seat in Congress in 2028," DDN).  So have some other Republicans who lost tight races.

Labels: , , , , ,

Revisiting Eastern Market in DC

I wrote about my fulsome plans for expanding DC's Eastern Market public market into more of a food-culinary district complex three years ago, on the building's anniversary.   

-- "Eastern Market DC's 150th anniversary last weekend | And my unrealized master plan for the market"

I had put a team together to bid on and do a new master plan, but after we won--I gave one of the best presentations of my life--I got pushed out in favor of the architecture firm's own employees.  

And they didn't produce much.  The Market is pretty much the same as it was.  

-- Eastern Market Strategic Plan

In the comment section of the original entry, I keep adding food business ideas.  

The problem Eastern Market has is it's not really a destination, but it has to compete with the Navy Yard, Wharf, and Union Market, all within 3 miles--plus a redeveloped football stadium campus ("DC Council unanimously votes to advance master plan for new Commanders' Stadium campus" WUSA-TV).  And plenty of grocery stores.

Despite the smallness of the Market, it is a top tourist destination within the city.  It frequently is ranked as one of the best public markets in the US, although there are more than ten better markets.  It's small, hermetic.  But the weekend companion flea markets draw a lot of attention and visits beyond the Market.

(When I was back in DC in June I didn't get a chance to visit because it is closed on Mondays.)

To be able to compete with the other destinations, I think you need an artisan focus and approach.  That's what Union Market has done ("A D.C. foodie’s guide: All the places to eat and drink at Union Market," "The last wholesalers of Union Market," Washington Post), but there is still plenty of room to do more and better in terms of food.

E.g., have the city's absolute best coffee roaster and cafe, artisan ice cream, the best pizza, a brewery-brew pub, best seafood bar, bakery, and classes etc., to be able to draw customers from beyond the neighborhood.

Faidley's has both a raw bar and crab cakes.

I think of Faidley's the crabcake vendor at Lexington Market in Baltimore, a whole animal butchery at the Santa Ana Public Market, oyster bars like Rappahannock, a firm local to DC that had been at Union Market ("13 Places to Slurp Oysters in D.C. During Oyster Season," City Cast DC).

Why can't the cheese monger include great wines and prepared dishes featuring unique food concoctions like the best grilled cheese ever or exclusive pastas, fondue as a special event.  

I could go on and on. Etc.  (Note Eastern Market's Market Lunch is known for its breakfasts.)

How to expand the physical space of Eastern Market.  The main points of my grandiose concept were in part, to link Eastern Market, its alley, and the adjacent Rumsey Aquatic Center into a combined facility, along with a digging out of Eastern Market's basement, to expand, this part being modeled after Essex Market in NYC.  This would accommodate more vendors and make it a stronger destination.


Eastern Market building and the alley

The arcade of Leadenhall Market, London

The basement of Essex Market.  (The Market in Budapest also has a functioning basement, with artisan food producers.

Rumsey Aquatic Center, looking towards Eastern Market on the east, fronted by a plaza.

The idea was to create an arcade connecting the two, moving the pool to a different location, and having food related businesses on the ground floor and elsewhere in the "Rumsey" side of the building, alongside other community and civic functions.  But making it taller than the current high one story, to also include a top floor meeting space.

To accommodate parking, the idea was to combine and add new space and access to existing space on the 600 block of Pennsylvania Avenue, which are privately owned facilities.

I see the Rumsey Aquatic Center is being rebuilt, and the rendering somewhat shows "what could have been."  

-- Full Rumsey planning document, DC Department of Parks and Recreation

Although it doesn't have integration between the two buildings, nor an arcade per se.  WRT the new program for the aquatic center specifically, also see the Hill Rag article, "New Rumsey Plan Draws Concern About Pool Depth."

====

The seafood vendor in the Market has closed, that would be the opportunity to re-create it as a raw bar selling seafood too, provide more reasons to visit, and to buy.  According to Capitol Hill Corner:

... owner Richard Glasgow has closed Southern Maryland Seafood. The market institution was opened in 1936 by Charlie Glasgow and management passed through a series of his sons, ending with Richard Glasgow. The business went up for sale in 2024 but efforts to find a new seafood vendor were unsuccessful. The market is managed by the Department of General Services. A Request for Proposals is expected to be issued in coming weeks to find a new tenant compatible with other South Hall vendor’s and committed to offering fresh foods.

Labels: , , , , , , , ,

Thursday, November 05, 2026

Four ballot initiatives I watched

1.  Adding transit sales taxes to support Caltrain and other transit systems in the San Francisco Bay area called the "Regional Transit Measure" and a companion measure, Proposition H for MUNI, in San Francisco proper ("Big win for Bay Area transit as voters approve regional measure and S.F. Muni tax," San Francisco Chronicle).

The MUNI system has electric trolley buses (electric power works best on steep hills), light rail on the surface and underground Downtown, historic streetcars, historic cable cars, and regular buses.

Both passed.  Pre-election coverage said systems would shrink vastly if the measure failed ("A Bay Area transit ‘death spiral’ could double Bay Bridge delays, report says," San Francisco Chronicle, Bumper to Bumper: How potential transit service cuts could affect Bay Area traffic, affordability, and carbon emissions, SPUR).

People attend a rally against Proposition 40 on Monday, Oct. 5, 2026. Los Angeles Times.

2.  Also in California, a tax on billionaires.  It failed ("Billionaire tax ballot measure trails; California voters reject voter ID," Los Angeles Times) and a companion measure forbidding repeat referenda on such a tax passed. 

Of course, billionaires poured hundreds of millions of dollars into fighting the measure ("California’s Wealth Tax Vote Too Close To Call—But Billionaires’ Historic Opposition Campaign Appears To Be Working," Forbes).  From the article:

Less than three dozen of the roughly 260 billionaires who would be impacted by the wealth tax in California, Prop. 40, individually contributed $293 million to stop the proposal from becoming law as of mid October, according to the Los Angeles Times.

Google co-founder Sergey Brin, who first moved to California in 1993, spent $102 million (less than 1% of his estimated tax bill) as the far-and-away highest contributor, and former Google CEO Eric Schmidt came in second at $40.2 million. Kleiner Perkins chair John Doerr donated $40 million and Stripe co-founder and CEO Patrick Collison spent $33 million opposing Prop. 40, per the Times.

Billionaire Chris Larsen, Vinod Khosla, Michael Moritz, Kavitark Ram Shriram, Frank Slootman and Stewart Resnick all donated between $4.5 million and $17.5 million each.

3. Property tax reduction in Florida.  Passed ("Florida Voters Approve Sweeping Property-Tax Cuts," Wall Street Journal). 

To me this will be a disaster ("Efforts to exempt owner occupied houses from taxes in Florida and California").  Florida doesn't have an income tax.  Local governments rely on property taxes for operations (along with sales taxes, other fees, government payments).

Schools, emergency services, libraries, roads, etc.  From the article:

Florida voters approved the most consequential overhaul of a state property-tax system in the country, sharply reducing the tax bill for many homeowners while slashing the funding stream for local governments.

The constitutional amendment—which the Associated Press called as vote tallies showed a roughly 62%-38% margin of support, above Florida’s 60% approval threshold—was the most closely watched ballot measure in Florida. Rising home prices and other costs have fueled an affordability crunch.

The Florida measure is part of the biggest nationwide property-tax revolt since the 1970s as voters in several other states also decide whether to roll back or restrain the housing-related taxes.

The Florida amendment goes into effect Jan. 1 and poses a big challenge for local governments that rely on property taxes to fund services such as fire rescue and road maintenance. Many were already paring spending in preparation and now face potential cuts in property-tax revenue of nearly $5 billion statewide in the 2027-28 fiscal year, according to one analysis.

Republican Gov. Ron DeSantis, who championed the amendment, has said it would provide direct relief to homeowners and prevent local governments from undertaking wasteful spending on nonessential functions.

Ironically, economists compared the impact of the billionaires tax in California versus reversing Proposition 13, a 1970s measure that significantly reduced property taxes by 60% and significantly reduced the legal percentage of future increases.

Cutting--an initiative of the crazy Republicans in Florida--I think will be comparable to Sam Brownback's supply side income tax cut orgasm in Kansas ("‘The Kansas experiment’ should be a warning to Republicans touting Trump’s big, beautiful bill," Boston Globe, "The Tax Experiment that Failed, Independent Lens/PBS, "Kansas abandons massive tax cuts that provided model for Trump's plan," Guardian).

The cuts wrecked the Kansas state budget, had to be reversed, and led to the election of a Democratic Governor, removal of many of the Republican supporters in the State Legislature, and even perhaps, contributed to yesterday's win of a Senate seat by Adam Hamilton ("Former Kansas Gov. Sam Brownback steps into US Senate campaign to endorse Roger Marshall," Kansas Reflector).


4.  An pro-abortion measure in Idaho, which aimed to reverse the draconian anti-abortion law already passed, which has has severely restricted the provision of OB/GYN care in the state ("Doctors left Idaho after abortion ban, study confirms," Idaho Capital Sun, "Change in Number of OB/GYN Physicians Practicing Obstetrics After the Dobbs Decision," JAMA, "When Idaho Banned Abortion, OB-GYNs Fled. The Doctors Who Stayed Are Cracking," New York Times).  

It failed ("Idaho voters reject ballot measure on abortion, preserving the state’s ban, NBC News projects," NBC).  

(One of our neighbors is a fetal medicine doctor who used to have to go up to Idaho Falls once day per week to provide services.  The ban completely changed the practice.)

I thought it was interesting because the Mormon Church donated $1 million to the referendum campaign ("LDS Church donates $1 million to fight abortion initiative on November ballot," Boise State NPR).  

How can it be legal for a church/501(c)3 to actually make political donations--although I'm sure they have a 501(c)4 lying around for such a purpose.

It's a bit murky:

Under federal tax law, churches and Section 501(c)(3) religious organizations are prohibited from directly or indirectly contributing money, resources, or financial support to political campaigns, candidates, or political action committees (PACs).

Apparently this is interpreted only in terms of candidates, not ballot measures ("Why the LDS Church can wade into abortion politics — and even donate money — without risking its tax-exempt status," Salt Lake Tribune).  To me a donation in support or opposition to a voter referendum is a "political campaign."  This interpretation needs to be challenged legally.

Of course, they still had the option of using a c(4) which can donate to campaigns, but the donations to the organization paying for it aren't tax deductible it seems illegal to me.  And again, seems counter to the Church and State separation clause.

Except for the Republican Administration and Republican Supreme Court's continued privileging of religious institutions relative to what was seen as settled law.  Such as endorsing candidates ("IRS says churches can now endorse political candidates," NPR).

The workaround is the Republican AG in Idaho ruled that it's legal ("LDS Church makes $1 million donation to anti-Prop 1 PAC ahead of Idaho’s general election," Idaho Capital Sun).  I think it should be challenged at the federal level.  Although with this Supreme Court, they'd let it slide.

Labels: , , , , , , , ,

Wednesday, November 04, 2026

Most significant micromobility transportation event in 2026: Pedestrianizing Oxford Street in London

Reddit photo.

Last year in January I wrote the most significant transportation happening of the year 2025 was the imposition of congestion charging in New York City ("The most momentous transportation story of 2025 has already occurred: imposition of NYC's congestion zone," "Big transit/sustainable mobility stories of 2025").

After years of trying starting in 2017 ("London’s Oxford Street to be pedestrianised by the end of 2018 under plans by Mayor Sadiq Khan," CityAM), Mayor Sadik Khan of London, with new authority given to his position, was able to put into place Oxford Street pedestrianization, despite years of push back from the Borough of the City of Westminster.

-- Oxford Street area works, Transport for London
-- "Oxford Street pedestrianization is coming to London" (2018/2026).

------

Well, maybe just wrt micromobility.  Spain's continued crashing of high speed rail trains on a line that hasn't installed advanced signaling could be considered a top issue.  

I'd say the most momentous decision was going into the Iran War, the subsequent "seizure" of the Strait of Hormuz by Iran, the reduction of oil and other shipping through the Strait, constraining supplies, abetted by Iran attacks on oil and gas infrastructure elsewhere in the Mideast, and the subsequent rise in oil and gas prices in the US and around the world.

------

This pedestrian scramble intersection on Oxford Street was an early attempt at rebalancing favor towards pedestrians. 

Cities like Paris, London, Montreal, Thessalonki have city-wide mayors with specific powers, but at the same time the city is organized into sub-city districts with mayors and councils and more significant powers when it comes to local affairs.  And Westminster has been against for some time.

Mayor Khan's main power has been control of transit, Transport for London, and with a Labour Government after years of the Conservatives, he has more national support for this function.

Oxford Street attracts more than 500,000 visitors each day. Taxis make up around 1/3 of the traffic on the street, but only account for 2% of the people throughput (10,000 people).  Most people walk or use the subway.  

The closure was implemented overnight on October 26th.  Reddit photo.

Making this a reality took a change in national law
.  Mayor Khan's authority didn't extend to roadways and to overturn Westminster Borough said no ("Banning cars in city centres has worked around the world. Why isn’t London’s Oxford Street pedestrianised yet?," Guardian).

But it required action by the national government to do so.  From "Oxford Street transformation – the state of play as 2026 gets underway":
On 17 September 2024, he revealed that the then brand new Labour government was backing his desire to bring “the nation’s high street” under his command.

BBC photo.

One of the justifications of the change is the now not so new Elizabeth Line adds more transit-based footfall to the district.  

Another is the decline of retail and the belief that more purposeful activation of the street can help revive it.  With the change, buses are shifted to other streets.  

And it seems to be having positive effect already ("How is Oxford Street one week into pedestrianisation?," BBC, "London’s Oxford Street Gets Spending Boost After Going Car-Free," Bloomberg).  From Bloomberg:

The number of transactions in stores jumped 19% in the seven days starting Oct. 26 compared with the prior week and from a year earlier, according to data from technology company Adyen. Overall spending value also reflected the surge in visitors, rising 28% from a year earlier and 12% on the previous week.

The figures, from 40 stores on Oxford Street, provide an early test of whether banning traffic can boost an area struggling to regain its pre-pandemic pulling power, where spending is recovering more slowly than across the wider West End district.

One problem is cyclists riding through, rather than walking their bikes.  

Even though I am a staunch cyclist, I believe mixing cycle riders with pedestrianized streets is a problem and shouldn't be allowed because cyclists tend to travel much faster than walking speed.

In short, not every micromobility intervention is designed to be primary for every mode.  Just like bike lanes aren't for walking nor cars.

Lessons

Paris was the first city to introduce wide scale dock based bicycle sharing.

World class cities. I have a line about how "world class cities don't just take, they give" in that their introduction of innovation in turn allows other cities that aren't "world class" to experiment similarly ("World class cities and the development of new transportation technologies: Paris and electric cars," 2011, "How Paris beat the car," 2026).

London has plenty of pedestrian districts already, so do so many cities throughout Europe.  But like bike share--Paris wasn't the first, but it was the first city to implement bike sharing at a major scale--this is a highly visible change that over time will have impact on US cities, even "world cities" like New York.

Lots of pedestrian activity in the Financial District.  MIT graphic.

Like in NYC there is talk about more pro-pedestrian interventions like multiple blocks in the Financial District ("Data Show Why Mamdani Must Pedestrianize the Financial District," StreetsblogNYC) but no action.

The same went for congestion charging.  London wasn't first, but it was more visible than Stockholm or Singapore, and it led to "diffusion of the idea" in the US, to the point where NYC, after years of back and forth, implemented it to great success.

Tokyo's Shibuya District has foot traffic equal to Oxford Street but still cars are privileged.

Density and a shopping core are key to success.  But most Western cities don't have a street section less than a mile in length with 500,000 daily users on foot.  Oxford Street has 120 million visitors each year and 85% arrive by transit.  

Similarly, Asian cities like Tokyo's Shibuya district, Hong Kong, and so many in China do have that kind of foot traffic, and could pedestrianize similarly. Also see the Bloomberg article "London's Oxford Street Has a Message for the UK."

These days cities in the US no longer have shopping cores dominated by multiple different department stores.  If they have one, usually a Macy's, it's a big deal.

Better to take it slow if your city isn't super dense.  Start with one block in an area where it can be very successful and go from there ("Extending the "Signature Streets" concept to "Signature Streets and Spaces"").

Mayoral development corporations as implementers.  The second Bloomberg article makes the point that what we would call in the US "community development corporations" ("Ah, the H Street Community Development Corporation") are a way to cut through opposition, red tape and fear and make change happen.

Labels: , , , , ,

Scary pumpkin carved for Halloween, "Bike lanes" for people who oppose them

From the BikeLA Reddit.

Labels:

Yesterday's Election

I saw this yard sign yesterday, while out doing errands.

WRT the Election results ("Angry Voters Usher in Beginning of the End to the Trump Era," New York Times), it wasn't because of this kind of thinking, but it'd be nice to think so.

-- Country First website

I'll take what I can get...

I'm not going to say this is a reset.  I will say though that if the Democratic Party in some of these surprising wins (Texas, Iowa, Kansas, some South Carolina, etc.) continues to organize and develop the "ground game" then some of these "miraculous reversals" can become more permanent.

In Salt Lake, I participate on the community whining site Nextdoor, and while the State is very Republican, Salt Lake City and to a lesser extent the County are strongly Democratic.

That means the County Attorney and Sheriff positions are Democrat and they've been in office a long time.  One strongly Republican participant on Nextdoor kept pushing their Republican opponents as an alternative, saying "it's time for a change."

New Yorker Magazine cartoon by Ben Chase.

I jokingly responded, "why is it in all those Republican House and Senate districts across the state, that have been electing Republicans all this time, they aren't saying 'it's time for change, why don't we vote Democratic for once'?"

Well, in this election it seems like many did ("North Carolina Republicans might have had the worst night of all," Washington Post, "Florida Republicans narrowly avoid blue wave but feel impact," South Florida Sun-Sentinel), even in Utah, a bunch of hard core Republicans seem to be on their way to losing--some really bad ones, like the landlord lawyer writing tenant legislation ("As Utah continues counting votes, Democrats are on the path to flip seats in GOP-dominated Legislature," Salt Lake Tribune).

Anti-James Talerico mailers sent to a Reddit member in Texas
.  

We'll see if these trends hold up through the full ballot count--Utah is/was a leader in mail in voting, although they're dialing it back because of the Trump sycophants. A lot of early ballots in Utah are Republican.

Labels: , ,

Monday, November 02, 2026

Free transit (and bike) rides to the polls on election day

The US Supreme Court continues to support voter suppression by declaring sections of the Voting Rights Act Unconstitutional ("Whites Only," Mother Jones).

Many transit systems like Nashville, the systems in Los Angeles County, Wichita, San Antonio and many others offer free rides on election day, with the goal and objective that people can get to polling sites without having to pay.

Lincoln, Nebraska takes this a step further, adding the local bike sharing program, BikeLNK, to free election day service ("Free rides to the polls: Lincoln waives bus, bike fares Nov. 3," Lincoln Journal-Star).

It turns out that while the BikeLnk offer is rare, Metro Bikes in LA County are offering free rides too.


=======

Francis Silva on a BikeLNK bike.  A senior membership is half off, $50 per year.

One of the things I say bike share systems need to do is trainings and group events, tours etc., for promotion.  BikeLnk has such a program targeting seniors ("Aging Partners, BikeLNK bikeshare learning sessions begin Monday," Journal-Star), "Educating Older Adults on Bike Share," Better Bike Share Partnership).

Labels: , , ,

Wednesday, October 28, 2026

European Prize for Urban Public Space

Zuidpark is the conversion of a multi-block parking lot into a park with climate change elements.  Before that it was a section of shipping docks supporting Antwerp's port.  Photos: Isabelle Pateer Photography.

An annual competition sponsored by the Centre de Cultura Contemporània de Barcelona, the 2026 winner of the European Prize for Urban Public Space is Zuidpark, a public park in Antwerp, Belgium. 

-- Architect's write up of the project

  There were 25 finalists

The organization has a number of publications, of the biennial competition, and lessons learned.  Some are published books, and hard to get in the US.  The report for each biennial competition is downloadable as a pdf. 

Labels: , , , , ,

Thursday, October 15, 2026

October is National Community Planning Month: A program for Citizen Involvement

I never did get a PhD in planning (a big regret) but I wanted to do my dissertation on better citizen involvement processes, because outside of families with children in local schools, land use issues were the ones most likely to get the average citizen involved in local civic affairs.

I've been busy travelling or being sick or tired, so I haven't been writing.  I try to write pieces based on a theme, like National Public Lands Day in late September, or National Community Planning Month in October.

The American Planning Association webpage has some resources.  Next year's conference is in Houston in the Spring.  

They used to have a membership tier for community representatives on planning commissions and similar public bodies with review responsibility for planning and zoning issues that was individually based.  Now the planning organization joins, and individuals join under the group.  I don't know if planning groups at the sub-city scale qualify for this type of membership.

While I can be very voluble, I joke that I follow the lyric from the Talking Heads song, Psychokiller, "When I have nothing to say, my lips are sealed.  Say something once why say it again?"

Yes I joke I write the same stuff over and over, albeit with redos and expansions and even reversals over the years, because mostly my insights are the same.  And sometimes I have to change my mind, based on new information and experiences, which I try to do as well.

A public planning meeting in Montgomery County, Maryland.

The necessity of capacity building.  My biggest take away from 25 years involvement with a citizen advocacy perspective is that cities don't invest in capacity building and training to help citizens be better at involvement.  

To me it's damning that with each additional planning engagement they participate in, they don't become more knowledgeable, creative, and "better."  I have written about this a lot, and this is as good a sum up as any. 

-- "National Community Planning Month | Civic Involvement" (2025)

A few cities, notably Minneapolis with a program that doesn't exist anymore, Seattle, and Calgary, Alberta, are quite good at it, many aren't.  (In parks, the City Parks Foundation in NYC has a workshop and training program for park-involved citizens.)

Some communities have citizen academies, but I'll call that an idiosyncratic approach, because it's individually focused, not individually and organizationally.  Organizations as a whole need capacity development and the ability to pass on programs and best practice even as older members leave and are replaced by younger ones.

Plus groups tend to be somewhat hermetic and that needs to be addressed as well.  

Of course, the Internet is a great source of information on urban issues.  Urban Land Magazine is published by the main real estate development trade association and is a good way to begin to understand how developers think.

Libraries can be a way to organize and deliver such training, and create special collections of books, periodicals, and other resources on all aspects of urban planning.  Dallas offers the Grants Information Center and the Urban Information Center as part of the Government documents section, as a resource along these lines.

Originally established to strengthen the informational foundation for community development and urban revitalization efforts, the center provides tools, specialized resources, and subject guides tailored for researchers, city planners, and local residents

Money for travel/training.  Off site training is usually criticized as junkets.  People don't seem to have much respect for it.  When DC's Main Street program started out, they provided some funding to attend the Main Street conference.  But not anymore.  

My going to various conferences, on my own dime, like National Trust for Historic Preservation, Congress for the New Urbanism, APA and American Society of Landscape Architects when they cycled through DC, of course the Main Street conference, Urban Land Institute meetings, and other trainings lwas invaluable.  It accelerated my learning greatly, especially doing field trips as part of the conference.  

NRPA Exhibit floor at a past conference.

Oh and many such conferences come with exhibit halls and exhibitors and you can learn a lot from what you see there as well.  I just sent back over 50 pounds of literature I picked up at the National Recreation and Parks Association meeting in Philadelphia.

Maybe it has to be done through philanthropy and creating an endowment, but involved citizens in recognized groups should be able to get at least some financial support to go to such meetings, with requirements to do "after action reports" to share the learning with others.

Placemaking workshop as a training platform.  I don't think Project for Public Spaces does this workshop, "How to Turn A Place Around" anymore.  

They used to do one every year in NYC and then out in the field when asked to do so as consultants--I participated in one for Scenic America in DC in like 2004 ("write up").

I think every city should do a workshop like this every year, moving it around the city.  

Obviously, it would be held at a particular project or site, or more generally in a specific neighborhood, with groups in that neighborhood being co-sponsors and the lead participants, but also have the workshop open as a training bed, to other interested citizens, organizations, and city/county staff as informed participant-observers.  

One thing I found is that having a mix of people with deep local knowledge, and less local knowledge but more technical knowledge is that the "new people" help the long time neighborhood residents in seeing a place differently, with possibilities, rather than the "same old, same old."

The workshop is great for helping to develop a consensus about community priorities and initiatives, but not so detailed as a full blown neighborhood plan.

Together Bay Area conference.

Annual community conference.  Some parks friends organizations like Park Pride in Atlanta have an annual conference.  It's more for professionals but interested members/residents are welcome.  Friends of the Parks in Chicago includes community awards for people and programs, so there is a celebratory element.  The Together Bay Area open space group's annual conference sometimes includes advocacy activities as well as field visits.

At the state level, most bike advocacy, historic preservation, and commercial district revitalization programs (Main Street) have conferences too, and these can be particularly good.

Past entries on Community Planning Month.  Rather than write something new, past entries related to the month are still fully relevant and worth (re)reading.  Here goes:

-- "National Community Planning Month | Civic Involvement continued, Orange County Register's Be the Change" (2025)
-- "National Community Planning Month | A Planner's Bookshelf" (2025)
-- "National Community Planning Month | Citizen advocates matter" (2025)
-- "National Community Planning Month | Civic Involvement -- Sometimes you lose" (2025)

-- "National Community Planning Month: Resource | Planning Whole Communities Toolkit, Puget Sound Regional Council" (2022)
-- "National Community Planning Month: Schools as community anchors" (2022)
-- "Community Planning Month and transportation" (2022)
-- "October is National Community Planning Month" (2022)
-- "Planning books to read for National Community Planning Month" (2020) [to the public safety section I would add Peter Moskos Back from the Brink, an oral history of the implementation of Broken Windows policing theory in NYC, blog entry]

-- "Community planning, capitalism, and housing/real estate development" (2020)
-- "October as National Community Planning Month (and "defund the police")" (2020)

Labels: , , , , , , , , ,